View MenuHours | Open
Mon11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Tue11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Wed11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Thu11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Fri11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Is This Your Listing? Are you the owner of Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza in St Petersburg & Clearwater Florida? Send us more details! Claim Your Business Or Contact Us
Description
We are serving some of the best New York style Pizza and Subs since 1972. We offer dine-in or take out service, we promise it's worth the trip. We are open 7 days a week. Come and visit us now!
Upcoming Events
Places You Should Consider
4.6 
(26)
5501 Gulf Blvd, St Pete Beach FL, 33706 (26)Casual Waterfront Dining at it is best in the heart of Sunny St. Pete Beach! Come to Caddy's for our mouth-watering menu, refreshing drinks all while enjoying...
4.2 (7)
20025 Gulf Blvd, Indian Shores FL, 33785 (7)Waterfront dining, awesome drinks, free parking, great atmosphere, boat docks, gift shop of shirts, hats, jewelry, towels, salt scrub, souvenirs, and more!...
5.0 (1)
2109-D Main Street, Dunedin FL, 34698 (1)Best pizza in Dunedin and the Bay Area
Get to know Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
For 41 years we have been serving some of the best New York Style Pizza and Subs in St Petersburg!
Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza Photos
News & Articles
Where To Get Delivery in St. Pete on Halloween
Where To Eat on Halloween in St. Pete and Clearwater
Best Places To Eat in St. Pete For Labor Day
Catering For Labor Day in St. Pete and Clearwater
Best Restaurants For Father's Day in St. Pete
Romantic Restaurants in St. Pete and Clearwater With Takeout for Valentine's Day
Best Pepperoni Pizza in St. Pete and Clearwater
Best Places To Eat For July 4th in St. Pete and Clearwater
People Connected
Plug Updates
Say Something or Ask a Question about Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
Recommended Ratings & Reviews
Restaurant Atmosphere Food Service Cleanliness Bang for your Buck The Crowd Parking & Accessibility
Best pizza, garlic knots that are FANTASTIC they even have salads and let me order meatballs with out the sub bread for low carb. Everyone in the family loves this place from 7 years old to 68 years old!!
Pros: FANTASTIC FOOD
Cons: lines - so get there early
Rated the Best Pizza in St. Petersburg for as long as I can remember. Great Pizza!!
